Andrew Caldwell

1691 - 1758  (65 years)

• Name	Andrew Caldwell
  Birth	18 Sep 1691	Lifford, County Donegal, Ireland   [1]
  Gender	Male
  Land Sale	16 Jan 1738	Lancaster Co, PA   [2]
  	285 acres
  Will	23 Jun 1757	Drumore, Lancaster Co, PA   [2]
  	Recorded 1/14/1758 and 2/14/1759
  Death	Between 23 Jun 1757 and 14 Jan 1758	Drumore, Lancaster Co, PA   [1, 3]
  Findagrave.com	07 Nov 2023
  	See Notes
  Burial	Quarryville, Lancaster Co, PA   [1]
  	Old Chestnut Level Presbyterian Cemetery
  Person ID	I2460	Butler Family Tree
  Last Modified	6 Jun 2026

  
  

  Father	John Joseph Alexander Caldwell,   b. Between 05 and 09 Jan 1657, County Donegal, Ireland d. Between 03 and 30 Sep 1730, County Donegal, Ireland
  Relationship	natural
  Mother	Jane McGhee,   b. 06 Jun 1660, Ireland d. Between 18 Sep 1691 and 1740, Ireland (Age 31 years)
  Relationship	natural
  Marriage	1682	Ireland
  Family ID	F652	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

  
  

  Family	Martha ???,   b. 1694, Ireland bur. Quarryville, Lancaster Co, PA
  Marriage	1718	Ireland
  Children	1. Andrew Caldwell,   b. 1722, Lancaster Co, PA d. 05 Nov 1768, Lancaster Co, PA (Age 46 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]   2. David Caldwell,   b. 22 Mar 1725, Lancaster Co, PA d. 28 Aug 1824, Guilford Co, NC (Age 99 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]   3. Alexander Caldwell,   b. 1727, Lancaster Co, PA d. 21 Nov 1785, Guilford Co, NC (Age 58 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]   4. John Caldwell,   b. Lancaster Co, PA  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]   5. James Caldwell,   b. Lancaster Co, PA  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
  Family ID	F410	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart
  Last Modified	6 Jun 2026

  
  

• Event Map

  Birth - 18 Sep 1691 - Lifford, County Donegal, Ireland Marriage - 1718 - Ireland Land Sale - 285 acres - 16 Jan 1738 - Lancaster Co, PA Will - Recorded 1/14/1758 and 2/14/1759 - 23 Jun 1757 - Drumore, Lancaster Co, PA Death - Between 23 Jun 1757 and 14 Jan 1758 - Drumore, Lancaster Co, PA Burial - - Quarryville, Lancaster Co, PA  = Link to Google Earth

  
  

• Photos

  Caldwell-Andrew-(1691-1757)

  
  

• Notes

  --------------------------------------- 2 different Andrew Caldwell's - both with wills in Lancaster, PA -------------------------------------- #1 Andrew Caldwell 1691-1758 ** my ancestor (actually Steve's) ** - married Martha ??? - children Andrew, Alexander, John, and David - will written 6/23/1757 in Drumore, Lancaster Co, PA - recorded 1/14/1758 & 2/14/1758 #2 Andrew Caldwell 1692-1752 ** not my ancestor (actually not Steve's) ** - married Ann Stewart - children Andrew, Robert, Rachel - will written 5/22/1749 in Lecock, Lancaster Co, PA - recorded 12/28/1752 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Found at findagrave.com on 1/27/2023 Andrew Caldwell **** this Andrew Caldwell is a Frankenstein - parts from 2 different people - but mostly Andrew Caldwell #1 **** Birth: 18 Sep 1691 Lifford, County Donegal, Ireland Death: 27 Jun 1757 (aged 65) Quarryville, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA Burial: Old Chestnut Level Presbyterian Cemetery, Quarryville, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA Memorial #: 75943537 Bio: Andrew Caldwell The inscription reads: Here lies ye Remains of Andrew Caldwell who d. June 27th, 1757 Aged 45 years. Mistake on Grave marker with death age. (Should be Aged 65 years) Married 1718 in Lancaster, Pa. Family Members Parents Joseph Alexander Caldwell 1657-1730 ?? Jane McGhie Caldwell 1661-1691 ?? Spouse Martha Ann Stewart Caldwell 1694-1738 ?? died 1738?? ?? wife of #1 - Martha and wife of #2 Ann -- both listed in wills written 1749 and 1757 ?? Siblings John Caldwell 1682-1750 Elizabeth Caldwell Moore 1684-1730 Margaret Caldwell McJunkin 1686-1740 George Caldwell 1689-1779 Jeanne Caldwell Richey 1689-1785 Catherine Caldwell Dudgeon 1691-1763 Children Robert Caldwell 1719-1754 ** son of Andrew #2 ** David Stewart Caldwell 1725-1824 ** son of Andrew #1 ** Alexander Caldwell 1727-1784 ** son of Andrew #1 ** Andrew Caldwell 1731-1805 ** son of Andrew #1 ** John Caldwell 1736-1812 ** son of Andrew #1 ** Created by: Michael Bell (46911790) Added: 4 Sep 2011 URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/75943537/andrew-caldwell Citation: Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/75943537/andrew-caldwell: accessed 27 January 2023), memorial page for Andrew Caldwell (18 Sep 1691–27 Jun 1757), Find a Grave Memorial ID 75943537, citing Old Chestnut Level Presbyterian Cemetery, Quarryville, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA; Maintained by Michael Bell (contributor 46911790). --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Found at findagrave.com on 11/7/2023 Andrew Caldwell ** this is Andrew Caldwell #2 ** Birth: 1697 Scotland Death: 4 Dec 1752 (aged 54-55) Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA Burial: Pequea Presbyterian Cemetery, Gap, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA Memorial #: 23652365 Bio: Andrew Caldwell died in Dec 1752, leaving a wife Ann, and children: Andrew, Rachael, married James Croswell, and Robert; granddaughter Hannah, child of Rachael. Commemorative Biographical Encyclopedia of Dauphin County, Pennsylvania..., by William Henry Egle, J.M. Runk & Company, 1896, p 59. Contributor: LSP (46860931) Inscription: 55 yrs Family Members Children Andrew Caldwell 1723-1768 Created by: Gina Reardon-Gaddis (46772796) Added: 30 Dec 2007 URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/23652365/andrew-caldwell Citation: Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/23652365/andrew-caldwell: accessed 07 November 2023), memorial page for Andrew Caldwell (1697-4 Dec 1752), Find a Grave Memorial ID 23652365, citing Pequea Presbyterian Cemetery, Gap, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA; Maintained by Gina Reardon-Gaddis (contributor 46772796). ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  
  

• Sources

  [S25] Findagrave.com. [S46] See Documents. [S77] Will.