S Butler and S Hibbs Family History Our Family's Journey Through Time

Print Bookmark
James Moore Butler

James Moore Butler

Male 1784 - 1860  (76 years)


Personal Information    |    Media    |    Notes    |    Sources    |    Event Map    |    All    |    PDF

  • Name James Moore Butler
    Birth 1784  Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location 
    Gender Male
    Census 1790  Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [1] 
    age < 16(6) 
    Census 1800  Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [2] 
    age 10-15(16?) 
    Census 1810  Capt Green, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [3] 
    age 16-25(26?), wife Cynthia (Bennett), age 16-25(22), 1 other male 16-25, 1 other female 16-25, 2 females < age 10, 1 male 10-15, 1 male < age 10 
    Census 1830  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [4] 
    age 40-49(46), wife Susannah (Bennett) age 40-49(42), 2 others age 20-49, 9 other < age 20 
    Census 1840  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [5] 
    age 50-59(56), wife Susannah (Bennett) age 50-59(52), and 6 other < age 20 
    Census 1850  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [6] 
    age 66,wife Susannah-age 62, Sarah A-age 20, Louisa-age 17 
    Census 1860  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [7] 
    age 80,wife Susan-age 80 
    Death 1860  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location 
    DAR.org 15 Jun 2019 
    See Notes -- #A017611 - BUTLER, ELIAS - for lineage only 
    Person ID I1632  Butler Family Tree
    Last Modified 6 Jun 2026

    Father Elias Butler,   b. 1760, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Between 06 Mar 1830 and Feb 1838, Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location (Age 70 years)
    Relationship natural
    Mother Sarah Elizabeth Stark,   b. 1760, Anson Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Bef 1850, Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location (Age < 89 years)
    Relationship natural
    Marriage Abt 1778  Anson or Mongomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location 
    Family ID F195  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

    Family 1 Cynthia Bennett-xx,   b. 1788, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Bef 1820 (Age < 31 years)
    Marriage 1802  Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location 
    Notes 

    • Children:

      son Elias Butler 1803 - 1803 both in Montgomery Co, NC
      son Calvin John Butler 1810 NC - aft 1850
      - bef 1838 married Martha J ??? 1824 TN - aft 1850
      son Elijah J Butler 1838 Carroll Co, TN - in 1860 married Louisa Jane Poland
      son Aaron G Butler 1839 Carroll Co, TN
      son Enoch R Butler 11/1840 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1910
      - in 1866 married Martha A Thornton 8/1850 TN - bet 1901-1910
      son Clark Butler 1867 IL
      dau Mary E Butler 1844 Carroll Co, TN
      dau Harriet Butler 1848 Carroll Co, TN
      son Joel A Butler 1/1848 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1910
      - married Elizabeth H Butler 12/1860 TN, dau of ??? Butler and Cynthia E ??? b 6/1831 TN
      Elizabeth had a sister Nancy Butler b. 9/1862 TN died aft 1900
      dau Mamie Irene Butler 10/1897 - 1917 both in Carroll Co, TN
      dau Cynthia Butler 1810 Montgomery Co, NC - 1852 Hempstead, AR
      - in 1840 in Maury Co, TN married Joshua Brumbelow
      dau Sarah Elizabeth Butler 1/11/1811 Montgomery Co, NC
      son Elias Bennett Butler 1/13/1813 Montgomery Co, NC
      - bef 10/1/1841 married Eliza Justus
      - had 8 children
      son Horatio Eli Butler 12/25/1815 Laurens Co, SC - 6/15/1887 Grand'Anse, Haiti ?? SC - only child not born in NC?
      - buried Pleasant Hill Cemetery, Carroll Co, TN
      - ** See his findagrave.com page **
      - bef 1846 married Mary A Whiteside 1829 Maury Co, TN - 1856 Carroll Co, TN
      - ** See her findagrave.com page **
      son John Thomas Butler 1846 Carroll Co, TN - 5/1887 Jenson, Sebastion Co, AR
      - ** See his findagrave.com page **
      dau Mary E Butler 11/7/1848 - 7/28/1883 both in Carroll Co, TN
      - ** See her findagrave.com page **
      - married John Perry McKinney 1839 - 1917
      son James H Butler 1852 Carroll Co, TN
      son William L Butler 1857 Carroll Co, TN

      - on 8/26/1856 in Carroll Co, TN married Camile Smiley Lindsey 1840 NC - aft 1870
      - ** See her findagrave.com page **
      son Eli M Butler 1864 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1880
      son Horatio Butler 1866 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1880
      son Frank Butler 1868 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1880
      dau Savanna Butler 1869 Carroll Co, TN
      son Earnest Butler 1873 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1880
      son Edmon C Butler 1875 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1880
      son Jasper N Butler 4/1877 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1920
      - ** See his findagrave.com page **
      - in 1900 married Ruth J ??? 4/1882 AR - aft 1920
      - ** See her findagrave.com page **
      - 1900 census shows residence as Township 8, Choctaw Nation, Indian Territory
      dau Emily J Butler 1879 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1880
      son Reuben Butler 1817 Montgomery Co, NC
      - married Mary Tennessee Whitsides
      son Elias H Butler 10/2/1826 NC - 3/28/1887 Carroll Co, TN ?? - mother Susannah Bennett & not Cynthia Bennett?? birth yr?
      - ** See his findagrave.com page **
      - bef 1852 married Louiza Eliza Hare 1/14/1827 TN - 10/11/1897 Carroll Co, TN
      son Elbert 1852 Carroll Co, TN
      son Jordan Butler 1855 Carroll Co, TN
      dau Elizabeth Butler 1856 Carroll Co, TN
      dau Marthenia Butler 1858 Carroll Co, TN
      son Emisan Butler 1861 Carroll Co, TN
      son Elias B Butler 1863 Carroll Co, TN
      dau Viola E Butler 1868 Carroll Co, TN
      dau Amanda Arona Butler 2/5/1871 Carroll Co, TN - 2/14/1949 Madison Co, TN
      - ** See her findagrave.com page **
      - on 12/21/1890 in Carroll Co, TN married William Charles McAuley 5/5/1864 Carroll Co, TN - 1/6/1936 Madison Co, TN
    Family ID F1023  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart
    Last Modified 6 Jun 2026

    Family 2 Susanna Bennett-xx,   b. 1788, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Aft 1860 (Age > 73 years)
    Marriage 1820 
    Notes 

    • Children:

      son Thomas S Butler b. abt 1821 Montgomery Co, NC
      - on 2/1/1850 married Martha J Maderis
      son Clark Seymore Butler 1825 NC - aft 1860
      - on 1/19/1848 married Sarah Parks 1830 TN - aft 1860
      dau Mary Butler 1849 Carroll Co, TN - aft 1860
      son Brantley S Butler 12/7/1827 NC - 2/2/1873 Carroll Co, TN
      - 11/20/1848 married Susan Huffman 1826 VA - aft 1850
      son Hubbard Butler 1849 TN
      - 2 more children
      - on 3/6/1855 in Carroll Co, TN married Minerva A Sharp abt 1837 TN
      - had 7 children
      dau Sarah A Butler 10/6/1830 Carroll Co, TN - 9/4/1888
      - on 12/19/1850 in Carroll Co, TN married Duncan McMillan abt 1819
      - had 8 children
      dau Louisa J Butler 1833 TN
      - on 9/15/1850 married Carroll J Pickler abt 1835
      - on 3/2/1863 in Carroll Co, TN married Haywood F Harris
    Family ID F1024  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart
    Last Modified 6 Jun 2026

  • Event Map
    Link to Google MapsBirth - 1784 - Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age < 16(6) - 1790 - Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 10-15(16?) - 1800 - Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsMarriage - 1802 - Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 16-25(26?), wife Cynthia (Bennett), age 16-25(22), 1 other male 16-25, 1 other female 16-25, 2 females < age 10, 1 male 10-15, 1 male < age 10 - 1810 - Capt Green, Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 40-49(46), wife Susannah (Bennett) age 40-49(42), 2 others age 20-49, 9 other < age 20 - 1830 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 50-59(56), wife Susannah (Bennett) age 50-59(52), and 6 other < age 20 - 1840 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 66,wife Susannah-age 62, Sarah A-age 20, Louisa-age 17 - 1850 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 80,wife Susan-age 80 - 1860 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsDeath - 1860 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
     = Link to Google Earth 

  • Photos
    Butler-Elias-H--(James-Moore-Butler)    		Butler-Elias-H--(James-Moore-Butler)
    Butler-Louiza-E-(Hare)--(James-Moore-Butler)-1    		Butler-Louiza-E-(Hare)--(James-Moore-Butler)-1
    Butler-Louiza-E-(Hare)--(James-Moore-Butler)-2    		Butler-Louiza-E-(Hare)--(James-Moore-Butler)-2

  • Notes 

    • - ** See marriage notes for list of children **

      -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at dar.org on 6/15/2019

      Descendants List
      Member: -- Name Restricted -- Nat'l #: 648018 Ancestor #: A017611
      1.
      -- Generation Restricted --
      2.
      -- Generation Restricted --
      3.
      Search
      »
      The Said -- Name Restricted -- was the child of
      William Charles McAuley born on 5 - May - 1864 at Carroll Co TN
      died at Jackson Madison Co TN on 6 - Jan - 1936 and his ( 2nd ) wife ****
      Amanda Arona Butler born on 5 - Feb - 1871 at Carroll Co TN ****
      died at Jackson Madison Co TN on 14 - Feb - 1949 married on 21 - Dec - 1890

      Short Form
      The lineage enter for this line was submitted using a DAR Short Form application and did not record the full line back to the ancestor. The line connects to national number 628731.

      Associated Ancestor (Revolutionary) Record

      BUTLER, ELIAS Ancestor #: A017611

      Service: NORTH CAROLINA Rank(s): SOLDIER
      Birth: CIRCA 1753
      Death: ANTE 3-6-1830 CARROLL CO TENNESSEE
      Service Description: 1) N.C.CONTINENTAL LINE,SALISBURY DISTRICT
      ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at http://wc.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=:3205224&id=I35

      ID: I35
      •Name: James Moore BUTLER
      •Sex: M
      •Birth: ABT 1784 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      •Death: 1860 in Carroll Co., Tennessee
      •Change Date: 16 NOV 2005

      HintsAncestry Hints for James Moore BUTLER

      6 possible matches found on Ancestry.com Ancestry.com

      Father: Elias BUTLER b: ABT 1758 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      Mother: Sarah Elizabeth STARKE b: 1763 in Anson County, North Carolina

      Marriage 1
      Susannah BENNETT b: ABT 1788 in Montgomery County, North Carolina ** actually marriage #2
      •Married: 1820 in Montgomery County, North Carolina

      Children
      1.Has No Children Thomas S. BUTLER b: ABT 1821 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      2.Has No Children Unknown Girl BUTLER b: 1823
      3.Has Children Clark Seymore BUTLER b: ABT 1825
      4.Has Children Brantley S. BUTLER b: 7 DEC 1827 in North Carolina
      5.Has Children Sarah A. BUTLER b: 6 OCT 1830 in Carroll Co., Tennessee
      6.Has No Children Louisa J. BUTLER b: ABT 1833

      Marriage 2
      Cynthia BENNETT b: ABT 1788 in Montgomery County, North Carolina ** actually marriage #1
      •Married: 1802 in Montgomery County, North Carolina

      Children
      1.Has No Children Elias BUTLER b: 1803 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      2.Has No Children John Calvin BUTLER b: 1804 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      3.Has No Children Cynthia BUTLER b: 1810 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      4.Has No Children Sarah Elizabeth BUTLER b: 11 JAN 1811 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      5.Has Children Elias Bennett BUTLER b: 13 JAN 1813 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      6.Has No Children Reuben BUTLER b: 1817 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  • Sources 
    1. [S1] 1790 United States Federal Census.

    2. [S2] 1800 United States Federal Census.

    3. [S3] 1810 United States Federal Census.

    4. [S5] 1830 United States Federal Census.

    5. [S6] 1840 United States Federal Census.

    6. [S7] 1850 United States Federal Census.

    7. [S8] 1860 United States Federal Census.


 

This site powered by The Next Generation of Genealogy Sitebuilding v. 15.0.5, written by Darrin Lythgoe © 2001-2026.

Maintained by Suzanne Butler. | Data Protection Policy.