S Butler and S Hibbs Family History Our Family's Journey Through Time

Elias Butler

Elias Butler

Male 1760 - 1838  (70 years)


Personal Information    |    Media    |    Notes    |    Sources    |    Event Map    |    All    |    PDF

  • Name Elias Butler
    Birth 1760  Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [1
    Gender Male
    _MILT 1776  [2
    Rev War -- soldier 
    _MILT 02 Dec 1783  Salisbury, Rowan Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [2, 3
    Pay Voucher 
    Census-State Between 1784 and 1787  [3
    Montgomery Co, NC 
    Census 1790  Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [4
    age > 16(30), 3 males < 16, & 2 females 
    Land Grant 1795  Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [3
    Census 1800  Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [5
    age 26-44(40),spouse age 26-44(40), 9 children 
    Census 1810  Capt Green, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location  [6
    age 26-44(50?),spouse age 26-44(50?), 2 children & 3 others 
    Census 1830  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [7
    age 70-79(70),spouse age 70-79(70), 1 female age 10-14 
    DAR.org See Notes -- #A017611 -- soldier 
    Will 06 Mar 1830  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [2, 3
    Recorded 2/1/1838 in Will Book A - p.66 (or p. 39 or image 44) 
    Death Between 06 Mar 1830 and Feb 1838  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [8
    Tax Lists 1836  Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [9
    Findagrave.com 08 Jul 2023 
    See Notes 
    Name Thomas Elias Butler 
    Burial Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location  [1
    • Oak Grove Cemetery
    Person ID I1610  Butler Family Tree
    Last Modified 6 Jun 2026

    Father Christopher Butler,   b. Bef 1738, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location
    Relationship natural
    Mother Mary Catherine ???,   b. Bef 1737
    Relationship natural
    Marriage Bef 1752 
    Family ID F536  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

    Family Sarah Elizabeth Stark,   b. 1760, Anson Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Bef 1850, Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location (Age < 89 years)
    Marriage Abt 1778  Anson or Mongomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this location 
    Children 
     1. Mary Catherine Butler,   b. 1779, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. 1784, Williamson Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location (Age 5 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     2. John Franklin Butler,   b. 1782, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. 1876 (Age 94 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     3. James Moore Butler,   b. 1784, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. 1860, Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location (Age 76 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     4. Elias F Butler,   b. 1785, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. 1846, New Madrid, New Madrid Co, MO Find all individuals with events at this location (Age 61 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     5. Judith Butler,   b. 1788, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Aft 09 Jun 1870, Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location (Age > 82 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     6. Mary Catherine Butler,   b. 04 Feb 1791, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Bef 21 Jul 1860, Williamson Co, TX Find all individuals with events at this location (Age < 69 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     7. Mary Elizabeth Butler,   b. 04 Feb 1791, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Aft 24 Oct 1860 (Age > 69 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     8. Rubin Butler,   b. 1794, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. Bef 06 Mar 1830 (Age < 36 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     9. Nathaniel Cornelius Butler,   b. 25 Jan 1796, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. 1880, Blue Eye, Stone Co, MO Find all individuals with events at this location (Age 83 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     10. Joshua Daniel Butler,   b. 24 Mar 1802, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. 06 Nov 1878, Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location (Age 76 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
     11. Sarah Elizabeth Butler,   b. 01 Sep 1804, Montgomery Co, NC Find all individuals with events at this locationd. 09 Nov 1881, Carroll Co, TN Find all individuals with events at this location (Age 77 years)  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
    Family ID F195  Group Sheet  |  Family Chart
    Last Modified 6 Jun 2026

  • Event Map
    Link to Google MapsBirth - 1760 - Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsMarriage - Abt 1778 - Anson or Mongomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google Maps_MILT - Pay Voucher - 02 Dec 1783 - Salisbury, Rowan Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age > 16(30), 3 males < 16, & 2 females - 1790 - Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsLand Grant - 1795 - Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 26-44(40),spouse age 26-44(40), 9 children - 1800 - Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 26-44(50?),spouse age 26-44(50?), 2 children & 3 others - 1810 - Capt Green, Montgomery Co, NC Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsCensus - age 70-79(70),spouse age 70-79(70), 1 female age 10-14 - 1830 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsWill - Recorded 2/1/1838 in Will Book A - p.66 (or p. 39 or image 44) - 06 Mar 1830 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsDeath - Between 06 Mar 1830 and Feb 1838 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsTax Lists - 1836 - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
    Link to Google MapsBurial - - Carroll Co, TN Link to Google Earth
     = Link to Google Earth 

  • Photos
    Rev-War-Vet--Butler-Elias
    Rev-War-Vet--Butler-Elias

  • Notes 


    • - 'The Miller'

      - can find no evidence his first name was Thomas --

      --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:Q2WT-GWJP

      Name: Elias Butler ****
      Event Type: Military Service ****
      Event Date: 02 Dec 1783 ****
      Event Place: Salisbury, Rowan, North Carolina, United States
      Event Place: Salisbury, , North Carolina, United States
      Gender: Male
      GS Film Number:
      Digital Folder Number: 004320473
      Image Number: 00365

      Citing this Record
      "North Carolina Revolutionary Pay Vouchers, 1779-1782," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:Q2WT-GWJP : accessed 3 January 2019), Elias Butler, 02 Dec 1783; citing Salisbury, Rowan, North Carolina, United States, State Archives of North Carolina, Raleigh.
      --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at DAR.org

      BUTLER, ELIAS Ancestor #: A017611

      Service: NORTH CAROLINA Rank: SOLDIER
      Birth: CIRCA 1753
      Death: ANTE 3-6-1830 CARROLL CO TENNESSEE
      Service Description: 1) N.C.CONTINENTAL LINE,SALISBURY DISTRICT
      Residence
      Created: 2002-03-27 23:23:55.3, Updated: 2007-06-22 14:08:38.0, By: tgill
      1) District: SALISBURY DIST - State: NORTH CAROLINA

      Spouse
      Number Name
      Created: 2002-03-27 23:17:13.16, Updated: 2002-03-27 23:17:13.16, By: Conversion
      1) SARAH X

      Hint: Click on the member number to see more.
      Associated Applications and Supplementals

      Nat’l Num Add Vol. Docs Child [Spouse #] Spouse

      628731 ELIZABETH [1] WILLIAM MCAULEY Purchase
      628732 Z S ELIZABETH [1] WILLIAM MCAULEY Purchase
      648018 Z S ELIZABETH [1] WILLIAM MCAULEY Purchase
      765663 ELIZABETH [1] WILLIAM MCAULEY Purchase

      = Supporting documentation available
      = Descendants list available for this member and this ancestor
      = Descendants list available for this member but not this ancestor
      -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at http://wc.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=:3205224&id=I1340

      ID: I1340
      •Name: Elias BUTLER
      •Sex: M
      •Birth: ABT 1758 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      •Death: FEB 1838 in Carroll Co., Tennessee
      •Occupation: Miller
      •Note:

      Fought in Revolutionary War. **************

      In 1823 they moved from North Carolina to Tennessee, along with their married children.

      •Change Date: 16 NOV 2005

      HintsAncestry Hints for Elias BUTLER

      3 possible matches found on Ancestry.com Ancestry.com

      Father: Christopher IV BUTLER b: BEF 1738 in Anson County, North Carolina
      Mother: Mary Catherine MARTIN ****

      Marriage
      1 Sarah Elizabeth STARKE b: 1763 in Anson County, North Carolina
      •Married:
      Children
      1.Has No Children Mary Catherine BUTLER b: 1779 ** can find no evidence of this child **
      2.Has Children John Franklin BUTLER b: 1783 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      3.Has Children James Moore BUTLER b: ABT 1784 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      4.Has No Children Elias F. BUTLER b: 1785 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      5.Has No Children Judith "Judah" BUTLER b: 1788 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      6.Has No Children "Mary" Catherine BUTLER b: ABT 1789 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      7.Has No Children Mary "Elizabeth" BUTLER b: 4 FEB 1791 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      8.Has Children Reuben BUTLER b: 1794 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      9.Has Children Nathaniel Cornelius "Neely" BUTLER b: 25 JAN 1796 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      10.Has No Children Sarah BUTLER b: 1798 ?? 2 Sarah's - can find no evidence of her
      11.Has Children Joshua Daniel BUTLER b: 21 MAR 1802 in Montgomery County, North Carolina
      12.Has Children Sarah (2nd) BUTLER b: 1 SEP 1804 in Montgomery County, North Carolina ?? 2 Sarah's
      -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at findagrave.com on 7/8/2023

      Thomas Elias Butler ** -- can find no evidence his first name was Thomas **

      Birth: 1760
      Death: Feb 1838 (aged 77-78) Carroll County, Tennessee, USA
      Burial: Oak Grove Church Cemetery, Buena Vista, Carroll County, Tennessee, USA
      Memorial #: 76971926
      Bio:
      Reuben BUTLER birth: about 1790

      Elizabeth BUTLER birth: about 1790

      John Franklyn BUTLER birth: about 1795

      Neely BUTLER birth: 15 January 1796

      Joshua BUTLER birth: about 1802

      Sarah BUTLER birth: 1 September 1804
      death: 9 September 1881

      Mary C. BUTLER birth: about 1806

      Elias F BUTLER birth: about 1808

      Judah BUTLER birth: about 1810

      James Martin BUTLER birth: 14 July 1824

      children:
      James M Butler

      Family Members
      Spouse
      Sarah Elizabeth Starke Butler 1760-1850
      Children
      Mary Catherine Butler Queen 1779-1859
      Mary Elizabeth Butler McAuley 1791-Unknown
      Judith Butler Boyd 1791-1870
      Thomas Butler 1792-1865
      John Franklin Butler 1795-Unknown
      Nathaniel Cornelius Butler 1796-1880
      Joshua Daniel Butler 1802-1878
      Sarah Elizabeth Butler Bobbitt 1804-1881
      Created by: Nancy Jane Faulk White Adams (15286517)
      Added: 23 Sep 2011
      URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/76971926/thomas-elias-butler
      Citation: Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/76971926/thomas-elias-butler: accessed 08 July 2023), memorial page for Thomas Elias Butler (1760-Feb 1838), Find a Grave Memorial ID 76971926, citing Oak Grove Church Cemetery, Buena Vista, Carroll County, Tennessee, USA; Maintained by Nancy Jane Faulk White Adams (contributor 15286517).
      -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at findagrave.com bef 7/8/2023

      Thomas Elias Butler ** -- can find no evidence his first name was Thomas **

      Birth: 1760
      Death: Feb., 1838
      Carroll County
      Tennessee, USA

      Reuben BUTLER birth: about 1790

      Elizabeth BUTLER birth: about 1790

      John Franklyn BUTLER birth: about 1795

      Neely BUTLER birth: 15 January 1796

      Joshua BUTLER birth: about 1802

      Sarah BUTLER birth: 1 September 1804
      death: 9 September 1881

      Mary C. BUTLER birth: about 1806

      Elias F BUTLER birth: about 1808

      Judah BUTLER birth: about 1810

      James Martin BUTLER birth: 14 July 1824

      children:
      James M Butler

      Family links:
      Spouse:
      Sarah Elizabeth Starke Butler (1760 - 1850)

      Children:
      Mary Catherine Butler Queen*
      Mary Elizabeth Butler McAuley (1791 - ____)*
      Judith Butler Boyd (1791 - 1870)*
      John Franklin Butler (1795 - ____)*
      Nathaniel Cornelius Butler (1796 - 1880)*
      Joshua Daniel Butler (1802 - 1878)*
      Sarah Elizabeth Butler Bobbitt (1804 - 1881)*

      *Calculated relationship

      Burial:
      Oak Grove Cemetery
      Carroll County
      Tennessee, USA

      Created by: Nancy Jane Faulk White ...
      Record added: Sep 23, 2011
      Find A Grave Memorial# 76971926
      -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at ????

      WILL-------------------------------------------------------

      Title: WILLS: TNN., Carroll Co - BUTLER, Elias
      Author: Court Records - Will Book I
      Text: BUTLER, Elias - page 65, names wife, sons John, James, Elias, Joshua, Neely;
      daughters Mary, Judah, Elizabeth, Sarah
      Text: "In the name of God. Amen. I Elias BUTLER of the County of Carroll and state of Tn. taking into consideration the mortality of my own body and that it is appointed for all men once to die--do make and ordain this my last will and testament--principally and foremost I give my soul to the hands of the Almighty god that gave it and my body to be buried in a Christian like manner at the discretion of my executors--As to all my worldly goods which it hath pleased god to help me with I dispose of them in the following manner viz:

      First I leave unto my beloved wife Sarah every part or parcel of my estate which I now own during her life time--(what I have already given unto my children in no wise herein included) and after the death of my said beloved wife Sarah I give and bequeath unto JOHN BUTLER, JAMES M. BUTLER, ELIAS BUTLER, JOSHUA BUTLER, NEALLY BUTLER my five sons--my daughter MARY QUEEN, JUDAH BOYD, ELIZABETH McAULY, and SARAH BOYD each of them one tenth part of the above mentioned estate by this will loaned to my said wife Sarah as much as may be remaining at her my said wife's death to them and their heirs forever--and I give and bequeath unto the children of my son RUBIN BUTLER, deceased, viz SUSANAH, LUCY and SARAH to be equally divided between them the one tenth part of the above named estate to them and their heirs forever--& do hereby constitute my two
      sons NEALLY Butler and JOSHUA Butler executors to this my last will and testament.

      In the witness of this being my last will and testament I the said Elias Butler hath hereunto set my hand & seal this 6th day of March 1836, revoking all wills heretofore made by me.

      Signed, published and declared to be the last will of the testator of us:
      ISAAC KIRBY, THOMAS BUTLER, ELIAS BUTLER."

      -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      found at http://familytreemaker.genealogy.com/users/p/i/l/Tenita-E-Piland/GENE6-0024.html

      74. ELIAS21 BUTLER (CHRISTOPHER VI20, JACOB19, CHRISTOPHER III (THE MARINER)18, CHRISTOPHER II17, JOHN VI16, THOMAS II15, THOMAS14, JOHN IV BUTLER OF LITTELL13 BIRCHALL, JOHN BUTLER III OF12 STARNBROOKE, GEORGE BUTLER OF11, JOHN WILLIAM10 BUTLER, WILLIAM III9, WILLIAM II BUTLER OF8 DROITWICH, WILLIAM BUTLER I OF7, NICHOLAS BUTLER OF6 YATTON, JOHN II BUTLER KNIGHT OF THE5 SHIRE, JOHN4 BUTLER, ROBERT3 LE BOTELER, ROBERTUS2, THOMAS1 PINCERNA) was born 1758, and died 1838. He married SARAH ELIZABETH STARKE, daughter of JAMES STARKE and MARY FRANKLIN. She was born 1763, and died 1840.

      Notes for ELIAS BUTLER:
      The History of Elias Butler, the Miller
      North Carolina to Tennessee

      Elias Butler was born in 1758 in Anson County, North Carolina. He was the son of Christopher Butler (VI). He married Sarah Elizabeth Stark, the daughter of James Starke and Mary Elizabeth Franklin in about 1778. Elias served in the Revolutionary War in the Continental Line of North Carolina from the Salisbury District enlisting in 1780 (he served under General Lillington.) The same year he had a watermill on Rock Creek in Montgomery Co. By 1792 (after losing his first mill) Elias Butler had a growing family and had built a new mill on Rock Creek, a few hundred yards down from the first. In the reconstructed 1784-87 census he is shown to possess one slave. On January 4, 1793, he sold the land that he had inherited and is listed as insolvent in Duplin County in 1794. He must have kept his mill in Montgomery Co. as he witnessed a deed there that same year. He was living there in 1800.

      Elias Butler in Carroll County, Tennessee

      The flood of people from North Carolina, encouraged by the offering of free land for military service, brought the Butler's with it. Around 1823, Elias and Sarah were moving to Carroll County, Tennessee and were among the first settlers of this area in the western part of the state. Their nine remaining children and their spouses accompanied them, as did the three daughters of their deceased son Reuben and their mother Susan. The Butler family apparently entered Carroll County by water. There were few roads at that time leading west, so they likely went by flat-boat up the Cumberland River to the Mississippi, then a few miles down the Mississippi to the Tennessee River. They would have poled up the Tennessee to the Sandy River which flows into Carroll County. There they settled along the Sandy River. Joshua, James M. (II) and Levi Butler all ran watermills on that river. Elias' children and their descendants spread over the county and to Arkansas where an area was named for them called Butler's Barrens. Though they rarely rose to high public office, they made their name in small business and in prosperous farming. Due partly to their large number, the Butler family was an important force in Carroll County in the nineteenth century.

      The Will of Elias Butler - 1836

      The text of the copy of the Will of Elias Butler begins on page 65 in the Carroll County Will Book I. What follows is that text:

      In the name of God Amen. I Elias Butler of the County of Carroll & state of Tennessee taking into consideration the mortality of my own body and that it is appointed for all men once to die...do make and ordain this my last will and testament. Principally and foremost I give my soul to the hands of the Almighty God that gave it & my body to be buried in a Christian like manner at the discretion of my executors. As to all my worldly goods which it hath pleased God to help me with I dispose of them in the following manner:

      First I leave unto my beloved wife Sarah every part or parcel of my estate which I now own during her life time. (what I have already given unto my children in no wise herein included) and after the death of said beloved wife Sarah I give and bequeath unto John Butler, James M. Butler, Elias Butler, Neally Butler, Joshua Butler, my five sons; my daughter Mary Queen, Judah Boyd, Elizabeth McAuly & Sarah Boyd each of them one tenth part of the above mentioned estate by this will loaned to my said wife Sarah as much as may be remaining at her, my said wife's death to them and their heirs forever...and I give and bequeath unto the children of my son Reuben Butler deceased viz Susanah, Lucy & Sarah to be equally divided between them the one tenth part of the above named estate to them and their heirs forever..& do hereby constitute my two sons Neally Butler and Joshua Butler executors to this my last will and testament. In the witness of this being my last will and testament. I the said Elias Butler hath hereunto set my hand and seal this 6th day of March 1836 revoking all wills heretofore made by me. Signed published and declared to be the last will of the testator of us. Isaac Kirby, Thomas Butler, Elias Butler.

      More About ELIAS BUTLER:
      Occupation: Miller

      Children of ELIAS BUTLER and SARAH STARKE are:
      i. MARY CATHERINE22 BUTLER, b. 1779; d. 1784.
      Notes for MARY CATHERINE BUTLER:
      Died at age five.Another daughter was given the same name after her death. It is likely that both were named after Elias' mother.

      ii. JAMES MOORE BUTLER, b. 1785; m. (1) SUSANNAH BENNETT; b. Abt. 1790; m. (2) CYNTHIA BENNETT, 1802; b. Abt. 1790; d. 1860.
      More About JAMES BUTLER and CYNTHIA BENNETT:
      Marriage: 1802

      iii. JOHN FRANKLIN BUTLER, b. 1782; m. PHOEBE ADELINE WINDSOR SALOMONS, 1801; b. Abt. 1782; d. Abt. 1865.
      More About JOHN BUTLER and PHOEBE SALOMONS:
      Marriage: 1801

      iv. ELIAS F. BUTLER, b. 1785; m. (1) ELIZABETH BRIGHAM; b. Abt. 1789; m. (2) CLARRAH CLARK, 1814; b. Abt. 1790.
      More About ELIAS BUTLER and CLARRAH CLARK:
      Marriage: 1814

      v. JUDITH " JUDAH " BUTLER, b. 1788; m. JOHN K. BOYD; b. Abt. 1785.
      vi. MARY CATHERINE BUTLER, b. 1789, Montgomery County,North Carolina; m. REUBEN QUEEN, Abt. 1804, North Carolina; b. Abt. 1785; d. 1859, Williamson County,Texas.
      More About REUBEN QUEEN and MARY BUTLER:
      Marriage: Abt. 1804, North Carolina

      96. vii. MARY "ELIZABETH" BUTLER, b. February 04, 1791, Montgomery County,North Carolina.
      viii. RUEBEN BUTLER, b. 1794; d. Bef. 1830; m. SUSAN BUTLER; b. Abt. 1795.
      ix. NATHANIEL CORNELIUS "NEALY" BUTLER, b. January 25, 1796; d. 1880; m. AMY ARINA OZIER; b. Abt. 1800.
      x. SARAH BUTLER, b. 1798; d. 1798.
      xi. JOSHUA DANIEL BUTLER, b. March 21, 1802; d. November 06, 1878; m. MARY "DRUCILLA" BLOUNT, Bef. 1832; b. Abt. 1805.
      More About JOSHUA BUTLER and MARY BLOUNT:
      Marriage: Bef. 1832

      xii. SARAH BUTLER, b. September 01, 1804; d. November 09, 1881; m. (1) JOSEPH BOBBITT; b. Abt. 1802; m. (2) THOMAS R. BOYD, February 21, 1822; b. Abt. 1800.
      More About THOMAS BOYD and SARAH BUTLER:
      Marriage: February 21, 1822
      ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  • Sources 
    1. [S25] Findagrave.com.

    2. [S48] See Notes.

    3. [S43] Military documents.

    4. [S1] 1790 United States Federal Census.

    5. [S2] 1800 United States Federal Census.

    6. [S3] 1810 United States Federal Census.

    7. [S5] 1830 United States Federal Census.

    8. [S77] Will.

    9. [S46] See Documents.